My flock of welsummers (30) do a good job of raising their chicks, Out of the 10 first ones that I bought, I had 2 to go broody their second year. They have done a good job brooding and raising their chicks, they are very protective of them. One broody named momma is docile and did not mind me checking her eggs during her brood, and was not too mean with me handeling her chicks.
She hatched 11 of her 13 eggs.
The other hen named bossy butt, almost tore me fingers off ( not literly) when I would try to check her eggs, and there is no way that anyone could handle her chicks, she ended up hatching 6 of
the 8 eggs she was sitting on, she brooded her own hatchlings and adopted 15 chicks from the incubator.
Guess that was a dirty trick to play on her, for her to go to sleep one night with her own 6 and then wake up with 15 more, she raised that group of 21 babies to about 5 weeks, then she was done, after she stopped staying with them all of the time if the other chickens were to bother the babies, make them squak or chase them, the fight would be on.
Bossy Butt is the top hen and has her own group of insubornates from that brood ( well the females anyways, the males are gone). These girls did this brood this summer in june and july, I have been trying to keep bossy butt and momma have been trying to go broody off and on since september, I have been trying to discourge them as keeping the 30 something chickens and the 3 turkeys over the winter is going to be enough to kept fed and watered.