Photo Critique Club

[casportpony]

I was playing around today and got some pictures of my muddy goose. Feedback wanted!

Original	Crop #1	Crop #2

Edited to add crop #2

 

[Nero70002]

Second crop is the best, maybe with a little more cropped from the right. I like the pictures though. *meant crop 1 second pic

 

[casportpony]

Second crop is the best, maybe with a little more cropped from the right. I like the pictures though.

Like this maybe?

 

[Nero70002]

Yes, maybe with a little more of the grass too, like having him in the bottom left corner with some space around him

 

[casportpony]

Yes, maybe with a little more of the grass too, like having him in the bottom left corner with some space around him

Can you show me how you would crop it?

 

[azurbanclucker]

I was playing around today and got some pictures of my muddy goose. Feedback wanted!

Original	Crop #1	Crop #2
View attachment 3481708	View attachment 3481709	View attachment 3481805

Edited to add crop #2

Crop 1 and shop out the foreground weeds

OR

Crop 2 and pull the left edge in a bit. The leading line is a good idea, it's just a little too far out. Pull it in to the closer edge of the dark clump of bushes in the left rear.

 

[Nero70002]

 

[Lacy Duckwing]

I was playing around today and got some pictures of my muddy goose. Feedback wanted!

Original	Crop #1	Crop #2
View attachment 3481708	View attachment 3481709	View attachment 3481805

Edited to add crop #2

I think Crop #1 is best. It's in a good position (I'm thinking rule of thirds?). Crop #2 is more of a widescreen picture, which is good on some screen formats.

 

[ButtonHoarder]

I liked your first image but I also think that getting the entire horse in frame would look better. I think if you would've taken a few steps to the left so that the horse was quartering towards you (maybe at a 20-45 degree angle), that shot would look good. I think the horse is a little too close to the edge IMO in your current crop. Maybe if you split the difference between your original and your current crop, it might work better.

I think this landscape crop works pretty good but it's not the vertical composition you were going for....

View attachment 3480909


And here it is with a slight lightroom boost...

View attachment 3480918

I do think that looks a bit better, thanks!

 

[Yard Farmer]

Can I post more pics for y'all to judge, would that be alright?