Quote:
so good for breeding but will this disqualify her for show? these are my nieces pet project and she wants to do real APA shows not just 4H
The male's a no go for either level.
I cant see that second hen you have too well standing behind the roos, but she may be good.
All depends on the judge. Some will let slight cockerel feathering on hens slide, some will shoot you down for it.
In the rear facing pic, she looks to be getting spur bumps too, so that may be something to have to contend with in a few months.
If she wants to get hard core about showing, in all honesty, she may want to get some more birds. These girls will do well on the 4H level, but in sanctioned APA shows, those judges will pick them apart. Not there's a hole lot wrong with them, but they can get down to feather count, and such in the tail. One little off feather here and there, etc, they can be super picky in the bigger shows.
Like Onagadori said, do you know where they came from? With these, lines mean a lot with what you can expect to produce from your birds. So even though these arent perfect, if they did come from a great breeder, there is the possiblity of good things to come from their offspring.
But based off what I see, the pullets will do better than the cockerel, he'd be DQ ed before even being judged on color alone