So many chickeneers have hatchery preferences and I think it's all the luck of the draw experiencing a hatchery order -- depending on climate/weather conditions during shipping chicks, handling by the USPS of the chicks, whether an order is placed thru a broker or directly from a hatchery, if any of the chicks got trampled in the shipping box, how stressed the chicks were when being transferred from the shipping box into the feed store's brooder, how caring or uncaring the feed store employees were with the transference shock, etc etc etc -- plus many feed stores get their chick orders from several different hatcheries and many feed store employees don't know what hatchery the different breeds came from. One of our nearby feed stores have local farmers bring in their chicks for sale on consignment. Healthy chicks are all dependent on these many factors in addition to whether they are coming from a clean breeding facility. I suspect that the majority of hatcheries have the cleanest facilities possible but so many mishaps can happen to affect chicks from their hatching to final delivery destinations sometimes hundreds of miles away. It amazes me that chicks can survive USPS shipping at all! A couple of my cross-country juvenile orders from private breeders were sent USPS but actually got flown to me by FedEx Air which is the airline USPS uses for expedited shipping. So many factors can affect chick quality going to their final destination.
Also, not every chick that hatches will meet breed standards (even if both parents were show champions). Breed standards are something to strive for but as we know not every chick hatches to standard or might even have glaring flaws like an extra toe, scissors beak, splayed legs, uneven wattles, funky combs, etc etc. Even show breeders have to breed 100's of chicks to get maybe one or two quality champion adults that meet breed/show standards.
I don't order directly from hatcheries since most require a minimum order of more chicks than I'm zoned for in my city. So I order the breed I want directly from my private local feed store who happens to order the majority of his chicks from Privett Hatchery. I get the feed store's money-back guarantee if I get a mistaken cockerel. I believe Privett has the most reasonably priced and widest variety of chicken breeds so it stands to reason that the little local feed store will order from Privett and that most feed stores on shoestring budgets don't order the Marek's vaccinations either. I once asked my local feed store why he didn't order vaccinated chicks and he said he had more chick losses with vaccinated birds because they'd have a bit of blood on them and the other chicks would peck them to death so he stopped ordering vaccinations. Whether that's a valid assessment or not that was his explanation and I'm inclined to believe him since vaccinations cost only a few cents per chick and wouldn't break the store's budget.
But I have not been disappointed in the chicks I get from my local feed store that largely uses Privett. A couple years ago I got the last Dominique pullet chick from my feed store and she suffered a seizure and died at 3 weeks -- it happens, chicks are delicate. I was so impressed with her lovely spunky personality that this summer I ordered 3 Dominique chicks from my feed store which said they came from Privett. I got 3 chicks fully expecting to lose at least one but all 3 are 9 weeks old now, thriving, and the pesty'est, friendliest chicken breed we've ever had. Hope their good health continues.
3 TINY CHICKS IN A KIDDIE POOL
THIS LITTLE GIRL HAD PASTY BUTT FOR A COUPLE DAYS.
AS CHICKS GREW THEY TOOK DUST BATHS IN THEIR GRIT
ABOUT 5 WEEKS OLD W/ BABY FUZZ ON THEIR NECK
ABOUT 7 WEEKS OLD
RIGHT KNEE CHICKEN - 8 WEEKS
LEFT KNEE CHICKEN -- LOVE THE BABY BLUE EYES
THESE DOM'S ADORE THE PETTING AND CUDDLING