Pullet or Roo Easter egger

[Vintage Roots Farms]

There are about 3 weeks apart in age. That another reason I’m having a harder time. I’ll post more pics. Appreciate the help

The one in back has big, chunky legs plus the large comb. No doubt he is a cockerel.

It would help to see a photo of the other one's comb/wattles. Judging by the difference in the thickness of its legs compared to the other, I think it is probably a pullet.

 

[GirlsHuntToo]

The back one is a cockerel but the front one is a pullet.

 

[JedJackson]

I think this one is a pullet. It does a bit of wattle growth, though, so I can't say that with 100% certainty yet.

 

[NatJ]

Thank you for your detailed response, everything I read online says EE are pretty hard to sex. But I was thinking the back one is leaning towards roo.. peacomb turned pretty red early. Was hoping for at least one pullet but that’s the name of the game.

In the newer photos, I notice that the younger one has a single comb, while the older one has a pea comb.

Once I noticed that, it is much easier to be sure which chick is which in the photos.

Based on the comb and wattles, and the feather color as well, I will say "maybe male" for the younger one. I'm not certain either direction, but leaning more toward male than female. I think that one is just going to need more time before it is really clear.

 

[SchwartzLakeFarmNC]

2 Cockerels in my opinion, both don't show any sign of a consistent pattern for female, and our EE's never produced a comb or wattles at that age and size.
I could be wrong but I doubt it.

 

[ve]

Front one is a girl. She is most probably Production Red, not EE.

 

[talkinboutchickens]

Front: pullet
Back: I would say a cockerel

 

[Vintage Roots Farms]

Front one is a girl. She is most probably Production Red, not EE.

I agree the color look different. Possibly different breed.. these are them shortly after i got them. Still think production red? The smallest one is the one in question

 

[ve]

The baby color is off for Rhode Island Red, or New Hampshire, but on the other side Production red is not very standardized bird, so some variations can be expected.
The bird in question has single comb, yellow legs and uniform reddish plumage, which is too much far for EE.
If you got it from hatchery, or Farm store like TSC, call it Production red.
If you bought it from person, or hatched it yourself, call it mixed breed.
Will be nice looking hen anyway.

 

[Vintage Roots Farms]

The baby color is off for Rhode Island Red, or New Hampshire, but on the other side Production red is not very standardized bird, so some variations can be expected.
The bird in question has single comb, yellow legs and uniform reddish plumage, which is too much far for EE.
If you got it from hatchery, or Farm store like TSC, call it Production red.
If you bought it from person, or hatched it yourself, call it mixed breed.
Will be nice looking hen anyway.

Thank you!!