I have no issue with e-collars used properly, on the right type of dog, and accompanied by training. The problem is a lot of people just put them on their dog and zap the crap out of them whenever they do something the person doesn't like. I've seen it over and over again and I've seen dogs completely ruined by such "training methods".
About a month ago I heard a dog making a big ruckus, went to investigate saw there was a border collie in the woods on the other side of my fence. It was steady yiking while running in tight circles, flipping through air and writhing on the ground. I thought maybe it was caught up in something, but nope, it was getting the zapped with it's e-collar by someone somewhere, probably from the subdivision next door. The dog obviously had no clue why this was happening or what to do about it.
A few years back I came across a little spaniel mix back in my woods that had not one, or two, but THREE e-collars on it. I'm guessing one was a bark collar, one was a fence collar and one was a training collar?? Who knows, but utterly ridiculous. I tried to catch the poor dog, but not surprisingly it was scared to death of me.
What bothers me the most in this forum is that people often recommend using an e-collar on very young pups that have had no training whatsoever, Like OPs four month old small breed pup.
It takes some time and know how, but I've managed to teach every single dog I've ever had (and I've had lots of dogs, of many different breeds) to come immediately when called. E-collars work, but when people rely on them they are most often depriving themselves of learning the finer points to animal training.
*I should add that I've never had either huskies or hound dogs.
