I haven't read all the responses but find I do have to say something that often does not seem to go down too well with others.
There are a bizillion kinds of butterflies. Have you seen how many different kinds of roses there are? Or how many different kinds of roaches, fish, birds, and puppy dogs? He LIKES diversity. He must, since he created us short, tall, fat, skinny, pretty, plain, black, white, brown, red.
I find it impossible to accept that there is only one way to worship Him--not with THAT flare for diversity! I firmly believe that whatever way you believe, all that really matters is that you DO believe. So whether you are Methodist, Baptist, Buddhist, Pagan, Jewish, or Muslim, as long as you are true to your heart, you are welcome in His house.
If you are Pagan or Christian or a little bit of both--He sees inside and knows you better than you know yourself. Trust Him.
Rusty