Thank you, Alaskan and Julio. I think they look beautiful--of course, I am no doubt biased...;-)
My dilemma is how to choose what to keep, what to cull, and how NOT to base that on appearance only. I have now read in a couple of different places of people having problems with Orloff chicks and young birds dying, or of birds that have weak legs or show poor egg production. Diet? Genetics? This disturbs me. What's the use of pretty birds if they aren't hardy, disease-resistant and reasonably satisfactory for meat and/or eggs?
(Soapbox warning) This same issue comes up in just about every breed of domestic animal that has any sort of following. Up until a few hundred years ago, there were no breeds--or vaccines--or electric fencing to keep chickens in and predators out. There were "landraces" that developed in their local geographic regions due to their ability to survive the cultural and environmental demands placed upon them. When you take a landrace and seek to stabilize it as a breed without continuing to subject it to the same parameters in which it developed, you will change the landrace. You impose your demands--be that a standard in color, an emphasis on a particular size, or any other criteria that are important to you. Even if you--and by you, I mean anywhere from a single individual to a breed organization--have done your very best to come up with a good, sensible breed standard, two things are inevitable:
1. You will change the original landrace
2. There will be people who object to the standard.
So, I guess each of us has to decide for ourselves what is most important in our breeding program, and that depends on our needs. If I am breeding to produce good farm animals that can thrive in my region with the least amount of pampering, my birds are going to be different from those of someone living in Texas--or someone breeding for show and sale to other people who wants their birds to be as close to the established standard as possible. Neither approach is better or more correct. I admire the work of people in both camps. everyone loves seeing gorgeous birds at fairs and in photos. Vaccines and NPIP certification are important if you are selling to others. (Now stepping down from soapbox)
So, what do the rest of you advise in terms of non-negotiable culling points for Orloffs--besides crossbeak and duckfeet?