MySIL brought me a lot of apples and I did not know what I was gonna do with them and Scrambled Egg put her crock pot Apple Butter on line. so I thought, quick easy and won't have to worry about offending him about using the apples. I got them done and had to just taste and man this was so good I almost sat down and eat until Icouldn't move. I added some Pure unfiltered apple cider vinegar.when I started to cook them. Now I will have to beg for some more,I have no idea what kind of apples they were but PLEASE TRY THIS RECIPE,YOU WILL NOT BELIEVE JUST HOW GOOD IT IS. thankx thanks thanks marrie