Scratch & Peck vs. Kalmbach

littlegardenhomestead

In the Brooder
Joined
Mar 8, 2026
Messages
19
Reaction score
29
Points
46
Location
Sussex County, New Jersey
I’m trying to decide what brand of feed to stick with for my chickens. I started out using Scratch and Peck starter crumble feed, but at $49.99 for a 25 lb bag, it feels really expensive, especially when I’ve been looking into Kalmbach starter feed is $20.99 for 25 lbs.

I noticed Scratch and Peck lists whole grains as the first ingredients, while Kalmbach’s is corn-based. I’m not sure how much that actually matters. I originally wanted to feed my flock organic, but after going through just one bag, I’m realizing how quickly the cost is going to add up, so now I’m considering switching to Kalmbach starter than moving into Kalmbach grower.

I’d love to hear your thoughts, would you swap to Kalmbach or stick with the Scratch and Peck organic feed option. I’m feeling a bit stuck on what direction to go before buying my next bag. Also should I slowly mix the two before swapping them to another feed? They are almost 4 weeks old. They will not be free ranging due to flying predators, and they will have a chicken run. Thanks!
 
Last edited:
Kalbach is the much better feed, scratch n peck is a"bougie, designer" feed. mediocre nutrition at a high price.
When it comes to animal feeds, organic is typically inferior nutritionally speaking, than normal feed. It's just a marketing tool.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom