Selling hatchlings...is this unreasonable?

Not unreasonable at all, explain that the price goes up per age. That's how it is everywhere. Also make sure he understand...non refundable.

 

I hold chicklets till people are ready but I do adjust the price to compensate for the feed

 

Sorry, but if one dies before he picks it up, you owe him a refund. You've got custody of them, you are supposed to keep them safe.

He doesn't get a refund if he decides he doesn't want them after you've held them, and you must have that in writing with his signature, because he is going to try to change the rules if he changes his mind, you can count on it.

Personally, I would not sell live animals to be given as Christmas presents to kids. But yes, I would expect to get some extra to cover their feed if I held them.

 

I think what Oregon Blues is afraid of is a phenomenon where parents view live animals as a form of toys for their kids. It's a pretty tragic thing that happens to bunnies and chicks around Easter. Once they get a few weeks old, and are less cute, they are thrown out like trash.

However, in this case, it sounds like someone who isn't looking for a cute little fluffy toy animal for the kids. By X-mas, the ducklings won't be in their super cute phase anymore, so that makes this less likely as an impulse buy.

And to answer your original question, I believe that you are entirely reasonable in asking for more money for feed and housing. Good luck!

 

Its not at all unreasonable to ask for more. After all, if you sold them to someone else, they might be picked up immediately and you wouldnt have the extra cost of feed etc. Essentially you're "boarding" HIS chickens.

 

I have done A LOT of business as a breeder of different animals, this would be very simple for me. Yes, I would sell him to them, I would price them at the time of purchase as if they were the age at the time he's picking them up. THE DAY he buys them, they are his and his responsibility, no refunds, exceptions being a predator kills them or neglect. If there's just an unexplained dead bird, it happens, you are taking the risk and boarding his animals at this point, normally there is a charge for that so word things kindly, be nice and accommodating but make sure you cover your drake feather at the same time!