- Thread starter
- #15,371
It's easy to forget here on BYC that the majority of the keeping conditions we read about and more importantly, see honest pictures of do not represent an accurate picture of backyard life for most backyard chickens.Caged eggs are being gradually phased out through regulation https://www.abc.net.au/news/rural/2...pdated-cage-eggs-battery-phase-out-/101347756 . We are very slow compared to the EU and some other nations who have made this change already. But the point is that the debate is settled, although of course all sides of the argument will find its way to the public discourse until the transition is over.
For example, one side of the discourse concerns backyard produced eggs. As the cost of eggs rises due to the transition to a free range only market, there is a spike in backyard chicken keeping, see https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-06-28/backyard-chicken-demand-egg-prices-cost-of-living/102534778 however, there is no official oversight of chicken care in backyard environments. If someone decides to keep chickens in a cruel environment in a backyard, it won't be susceptible to welfare inspections. At least the caged egg producers working on a large scale undergo welfare inspections.
The type of conditions I posted at the begining of the thread are not at all uncommon. Confining chickens to a coop and run only is not uncommon either.
The arguement that a well run battery provides better conditions than many, if not most back yard arrangements is I think a fair one.
However, many batteries are not as Dr whathisneame describe and some backyard arrangements are far better than the Dr suggests.
I dare say many of those pictures in the various show us your chicken threads are misleading. Sure, the chickens look okay but many are posed for the picture and don't tell us much about how that chicken lives day to day. It's why I like keeping condition pictures on this thread. It's rather more honest than the posed shots for a competition/whatever.
The free range or range or confined classification isn't very difficult but of course, many are reluctant to drop the word "free" because it makes them look all warm and fuzzy. For the meat and egg industry it's an outright con; complete bullshit for marketing purposes.
Free range is having no physical barriers that prevent a chicken travelling any distances it wants to. There are not many people who keep free range chickens. For a start one needs quite a lot of land.
Ranging would seem a fair description for the majority of keeping arrangments that don't fall into the fully confined class.
For how long the chicken ranges and on how much land and the land condition is what one needs to know to make any sort of assessment.
My uncle free ranged and I did in Catalonia. The chickens got injured, predated, picked up lice and mites and learn't to be very cautious about where they went and when. I think they were healthier while they lived than any battery hen and a proper comparison would be an interesting study.
I wouldn't free range chickens in most circumstances. Even given unlimited resources I would still range. It might be from dawn to dusk but I would want some physical barrier even if that meant securely fencing a few acres.