Is it an option to get him is own girls? I am so NOT an expert, but Kosovo's sons sound like ideal roosters for that group of hens, they were accepted. Scared and wounded hens sounds pretty intolerable to me. If you can give Big Red his own group of ladies maybe closer in size to his breed or larger (to give them the advantage..lol), and let the brothers have their ladies, that may be the ideal solution. You get to keep the Rooster you love, the brothers and their hens get to go back to a peaceful existence and Big Red has girls of his own again.
The two hens he had were Turkish line Brahma. Those produced Galadriel, who went on to produce offspring of her own, drastically increasing the diversity of the group (since Perris brought up the topic with that very informative article).
I really don’t want to have a third group here. Having a third group means having a third space, which takes away from the first two. In addition, having said third group would mean total confinement for that group, in quite a limited space, something that I’m not interested in doing again. I’m trying to “retire” the bantam pen as well. Not letting them incubate any eggs of their own, and letting them live out their lives.
Big Red is always in search of more hens, and it’s very unfair for him to go from over 10 to 2, and from more than 2 acres of territory, to a couple of meters