huh. Ok. so, in a 64 square foot coop that should be good for 16 chickens (at 4sf per large bodied chicken) you're saying I need 16 square foot of open wall? Sorry, but that doesn't make sense for cold weather. Please explain to me how exactly to do that and where you get that data point from. I've not seen it anywhere yet.
I live in northern Minnesota. Half of the year my chickens live in their coop - never going outside if there is snow in the chicken run. I agree that ventilation is very important, but there are many things that I believe affect that 1 square foot per bird ratio.
In my coop, I have almost 8 sq ft per bird, because I factored into the fact that the birds would be living inside the coop for 5-6 snow months per year. A larger coop, with more room to move, helps the birds be not so aggressive towards each other.
The coop build makes a difference. I have a gambrel roof on my coop, which is probably 8 or 9 feet high at the peak. The roosts are at about 5 feet high. So, there is plenty of air volume above their heads at night.
I have small vents in the peaks of the roof, on both sides, allowing for cross ventilation. I also have two sliding windows across each other about 4 foot off the floor for cross ventilation. I will close them if a winter storm is coming, but usually leave them open otherwise.
I estimate that I have maybe 1/2 square foot of ventilation per bird in my coop. But it works for me because I have a small number of birds in a big coop with a very high roof. Also, there is no cold air, or a draft, coming up from underneath the roosting chickens. My ventilation is at above their heads in the peak of the roof and on the opposite side of the coop from the roosts.
In 4 years of keeping chickens through Minnesota winters, I have never lost a bird to the cold in an unheated coop. Our temps can get down as low as -40F for a week or longer in the dead of winter.
Some birds have suffered from frostbite, but nothing that they could not survive. For a roost, I have a 2X4 laid on the flat edge. That allows them to sit on the 2X4 with their feet tucked into their body to keep warm. They also fluff up their feathers in extremely cold weather to trap warm air against their bodies and look almost twice as big as they do in the summertime. That is why you don't want any cold drafts coming up from below them. That would reduce their ability to fluff up their feathers and keep themselves warm with that trapped air.
I don't know what the perfect ratio of ventilation for your specific geographic area might be, but before I built my coop, I visited a place where our local Amish people build and sell chicken coops. They do not have that 1 square foot of ventilation per bird ratio in their chicken coops, either. But again, they also have high roofs with cross ventilation at the peaks. Again, the type of build and the number of chickens in the coop makes a big difference.
Hope some of that helps. Many things factor into that suggested 1 foot of ventilation per bird ratio. Certainly, if you see condensation in the coop, or other negative aspects of trapped moist air inside the coop in the winter, you should probably consider more ventilation.