I get what he's saying. My point is that if she is laying them in the wee hours of the morning, it won't help. She isn't going to get off the roost when it's dark. I guess my bad for taking away their light too soon. In a few weeks the sun will be up by then. I'll put something in there to see if that helps but I think she's laying them before the sun rises. I should have backed their light off but I figured an hour or so wouldn't make that much of a difference.