
Are Pallet Busters/Pallet Pals a good investment?
There is a lot of hype about how great the Pallet Busters/Pallet Pals are in quickly breaking down pallets. Those of you new to the subject, here is a picture of what a Pallet Buster looks like.
View attachment 3280179
View attachment 3280178
If you buy a Pallet Buster, you can find them from anywhere about $40.00 to over $120.00. Basically, they all work the same.
I have a welder at home that never gets used, so I made my own DIY Pallet Buster using 3/4 inch pipes. All parts cost me about $20.00. Here is what it looks like.
View attachment 3280182
The idea is that you slip the tongs underneath the planks and pry them up with all the leverage you gain by the 4-5 foot long handle. In theory, it's a great design. In practice, however, I have found that unless you have the right type of pallet with good wood, you more than likely will just crack and split the planks leaving you with firewood.
Problem is that most pallets I get have old wood that is already cracked at the ends, so when you use the Pallet Buster to pry up the wood, it only cracks and splits the wood even more and the boards get totally messed up. For that reason, I will use the Sawzall method to remove planks if I need long boards, or I will use the circular saw method and cut off the wood between the 2X4 stretchers and salvage lots of good nail-free wood about 18 inches long.
I estimated that I get maybe 1 good Pallet Buster type pallet out of every 20 pallets I bring home. Today, I want to post some pictures of what I consider a good type of pallet to breakdown with a Pallet Buster.
Here is a picture of one such pallet I just brought home this weekend. It is made up of new wood, this pallet is 6 feet long, so I really wanted to save all 6 feet of those planks.
View attachment 3280184
You can see that wood is new and in good condition. Rare for me, but maybe your pallets are of this quality.
One of the first considerations I have is how many nails are driven into each board. In this picture, you can see that this pallet uses only 2 nails per board on the 2X4 studs.
View attachment 3280185
This is one of the first signs that you might want to use the Pallet Buster on this pallet to break it down. Most of the rebuilt pallets I salvage have maybe 4-5 nails into each 2X4 stud - because the wood is old and cracking/splitting and they need all those nails to keep the boards on the pallet. When there are lots of nails to pry up, then the Pallet Buster usually just destroys the wood in the process.
Anyway, all the 2X4 studs had only 2 nails in the planks. Here is a picture of the middle of the pallet....
View attachment 3280188
Again, only 2 nails per board on the 2X4 studs.
Another important factor is the thickness of the planks on the pallets. I usually get pallets with wood planks that are 3/8 inch, 1/2 inch, or maybe 5/8 inch deck boards. Usually, the thicker the better. On this pallet I am posting, they actually used standard 1X4 boards so they were 3/4 inch thick....
View attachment 3280190
You can see that these 1X4 planks are in great shape with very few of them cracked or split at the ends. With boards like these on this pallet, the Pallet Buster is a great option to break down the pallet. In a matter of a few minutes (maybe 5 minutes) I had the complete pallet broken down and was able to save almost all of those 6 foot long 1X4 boards. It took me maybe another 30 minutes to pound out and remove all the nails. In less than an hour, I had a wagon full of nail-free pallet wood broken down and ready to be used in a future project.
So, the Pallet Buster was the perfect tool for this type of pallet. If I got lots of those type of pallets, I would be a great advocate for the Pallet Buster tool. However, I rarely use my DIY Pallet Buster because the pallets I get are usually not in such great shape as the one in this post. If you have a poor quality pallet, the Pallet Buster will make lots of firewood to burn, but you will not get much salvaged wood for use. At least, that is what I have learned.
Bottom line, I do not recommend the Pallet Buster as a must have tool for breaking down pallets. Save your money for other tools that will be used. I seldom use my Pallet Buster, and I'm glad I only invested $20.00 for my DIY build. However, it is the perfect tool IF you have the PERFECT pallets.

Don't believe all the positive reviews on Amazon for the
Pallet Buster they sell. It is listed at 4.5 stars after about 3,000 reviews. I call fake! Read the 1 and 2 star reviews from people who have actually purchased the Pallet Buster and you get a review more in line with my experience.

Would love to hear if anyone else has had better luck, or use, with their Pallet Buster. Or, like me, you find that it is a tool that is rarely used. I could live without it, but maybe some people have a more positive attitude towards the Pallet Buster.