Quote:
Hi Math Ace,
A solid white feather is not a DQ per the 2010 S.O.P.
If the breed standard does not say a white feather is acceptable , it reverts back to the interpretation section and cuttings for defects. A white wing or tail feather on the SS is a DQ, since the breed standard does say it is acceptable.
There is another pullet waiting for a critique so how about jumping into the thread and say how to go forward with this female. Don
I think at this point, I may need to invite a couple of judges to come over and give us their take on this issue.
We all agree that the White, all white, wing feather does not belong after the Juvie molt....
Punky and Steve seem to see it as a Fault.
If I am understanding Don correctly, he sees it as a Disqualifier.
I'll see if we can not get a couple of judges to see how they would interpret it in the show ring. . .
ALSO, the pics I post I do invite ALL to give their critique on.
I learned so much on the marans thread by reading others critiques,
but I learned even more when I started posting my own critiques.
Sometimes I was
totally off on vocabulary or concept. It was all good because the more experienced breeders would come in and GENTLY correct my errors.
I never professed to being an expert and everyone knew I was just learning right along with the others.
I invite anyone who is willing to EXPOSE themselves to critique my birds. This is a forum that I want everyone to feel comfortable to make mistakes.
We can learn through our mistakes and others' mistakes. If posting makes you uncomfotable, then by all means. . .. continue to LURK.
Just give us a "shout out" every once in a while so that we know there is life out there
If there is something you want clarification on BUT don't feel comfortable posting - ---PM someone who is posting.
They can post your question for you.
NOW, I am off to find a couple of judges to give us their take on the the solid white wing feather - - FAULT or DQ ?