Howhardcanitbe.....
Sandhill roo is 19 weeks old
Mc Murry roo is 28 weeks old
Mt Healthy roo is 37 weeks old
On average there is a 10 week difference in each bird.
The SOP calls for Cock to weigh in at 9 lbs AND Cockerels to weigh in at 7 1/2 lbs.
Since the Mt. Healthy roo was weighing in at 7.2 lbs at 27 weeks, he is going to set the standard for you.
Time to get that Mc Murray boy on a scale ASAP. I think you are going to find that he is over a pound lighter than what the Mt. Healthy roo was at the same time period!.
The McMurray guy just looks narrow to me. I KNOW Don liked this guy, but I don't like the long white blotches on his neck hackles. I don't like that his tail is so stiff without the curving tail feathers.
He does seem to have a wing issue too. It may be a slipped wing. Don will have to tell us what he thinks....
The Mt Healthy boy looks to have a wing issue too. It might be a spilt wing. It doesn't seem to fold in on itself correctly. Once again, Don will have to tell us what he thinks.
I don't like the wattles on this guy, nor do I like how much black he has on the chest. I would NEVER complain about a back being too long. There are always plent of short backed hens running around if you want to fix that problem LOL. If your hens look anything like mine, I would feel much better about using a roo that is too dark versus one that is too white.
I wish this guy's comb blade would of followed the head instead of sticking out in the air so much. I still like this guy more than the McMurray boy.
The sandhill guy is the BABY. At 19 weeks, has he gone through the Juvie molt yet? If so, I have to say that I am liking that I am not seeing any white in the wing or tail feathers. Although he is the baby, he weighs one lb more than the Mc Murray bird did at almost 7 weeks older. The weight thing just keeps coming back to haunt the McMurray bird. The Sandhill guy has a dark chest too. I don't think it is going to be as dark as the Mt Healthy roo, but it is dark. His comb has a twist on it, BUT I do like the size of the wattles better than the Mt. Healthy bird. I would have to give this guy some more growing time before I could decide on him. I would watch to see how his chest developes. He should end up with a DEEP AND ROUND chest. I am not seeing that yet.
I would start looking for some hens with open and low tails ( not pinched ), nice combs ( no twists or thumbprints) , tight and high wing sets and WEIGHT. You only need one or two hens. Find the very BEST you have and be selective.
Do you realize that 2/3 rd's of the points awarded to a bird come from the shape and condition of the bird? Only 1/3 of the points are color related.
DON, please, correct me if I am wrong, BUT I believe that when it comes to color, this is one of those breeds where the solid white feather is bad, very bad, DQ bad.
That is why on your roos you want to open the wing FULLY and see if he is hiding a white feather. The Mt. Healthy boy isn't hiding his, it is right out there in the open!
He has large white feathers in his tail too! The McMurry bird is narrow with weird large white blotches on his neck hackles....
I would be looking at that Sandhill boy carefully and see if he is hiding any white in the wing or tail. If he isn't hiding white, then I would start hoping that he developes a really nice chest
JUST my thoughts on the three Bachelors. I am no EXPERT and always defer to what ever Don says ( even if I think he is wrong on the Mc Murray boy
).