out of things i worry about with breeding silkies weight is low on my list at momentWith much respect, how can it be bull? He was absolutely correct about my bird. And he was right to DQ him, too. Or any other bird that weighed in too heavy or light. I didn't like it, but all the same, when I went home to weigh him, he was indeed over weight by several ounces and certainly not within the 20% weight allowance. Had I been more experienced and thought to weigh him before I left, I never would have taken an over weight bird to the show. This was my fault-- the fault of the owner. I look at it this way-- WE, as breeders, are responsible for ONLY bringing birds that meet the SOP. If our birds don't meet the SOP, then by what right should we be upset for being DQ'd? We need to always be ethical in our breeding and in who we select for our show birds. I have learned a lot by going to shows. These judges know their birds. This one in particular that DQ'd my bird on weight is VERY familiar with Silkies. He was an out of State judge that the show hired to come in. Judges are supposed to know the weight limit on all breeds and what that feels like. And if they judge many shows in a season, they know what they are doing. So far, all of the judges I've encountered have been much older, so I can only imagine how many years of experience they have had. They know what they are doing, whether they have picked up 20 birds or 200 that day. I'm not a judge-- and frankly never will be, there is no way I could pass the testing they have to do! So my respect for them is unequivocal; they deserve it.Ultimately, we can not fault a judge for our own mistakes.![]()