With everything, what makes the cull group versus what makes the keep group depends on the birds you already have, how far along you are in your breeding program and what you can afford. Ideally no one wants to keep anything except perfect birds. The reality is that there are no perfect birds. So, you keep the very best, or the ones whose traits yours lack and pass along those that will not benefit your flocks.
What is an obvious cull to one person is a keeper to another. If type is awesome, and other choices are lacking, single comb and toe issues are among the easiest to breed out (as compared with droop or split wing, wry tail, misshapen comb, etc.)
I'm at a point in my breeding where I don't want to keep or use birds with comb or toe issues except in project varieties, and even then I think long and hard about whether to keep or pass on. But a few years back I would and did. One of my best black cocks had only 4 toes on one foot, but he was awesome otherwise, great type and absolutely no leakage.
What is an obvious cull to one person is a keeper to another. If type is awesome, and other choices are lacking, single comb and toe issues are among the easiest to breed out (as compared with droop or split wing, wry tail, misshapen comb, etc.)
I'm at a point in my breeding where I don't want to keep or use birds with comb or toe issues except in project varieties, and even then I think long and hard about whether to keep or pass on. But a few years back I would and did. One of my best black cocks had only 4 toes on one foot, but he was awesome otherwise, great type and absolutely no leakage.
Last edited: