They're amazing egg layers. I have 3 and I get about an egg a day, except in winter because I don't have a light out there for them. Wonderful birds ! One of mine just went broody and hatched out 7 chicks ! My profile picture is her with one of her babies.Then I guess that's a positive. Are they good egg layers or are they meat chickens?
To me they both look like hens. I have a almost 6 week old rooster that's got bigger wattles then your girls.So just because they have red combs and wattles already doesn't always mean rooster. This whole thing is so confusing. I'm just hoping some of the twelve I bought are hens. Maybe I should just buy cheap hatchery chicks next time and take my chances. I paid $30 a piece for some of them. Ugh