When they can goto an Adult PRISON I think of them as adults. I find it disrespectful to consider them children because they aren't 18. They are young adults. They are still learning no doubt but to slap them in the face and say I OWN you piss off....
I read this post all day and have held back all day. Amazing some of the advice given.
Patchofheaven you said for the most part you have a GOOD kid you want to keep it that way right? I was the type of kid that when you grounded me my attitude was and IS forget you, what are you gona do to me now. (You should see me with Cops, Not a pretty sight.) {I have never been convicted of a crime!!!} It got to the point where I was not allowed to even read in my room (Already grounded from friends, TV, Nintendo, Magazines, everything). My Grandma came in and said "You learn your lesson yet!" I looked her right in the eye and said "What!! I've sat here for months, what next you will make me not stare at the walls!" She about gave up after that and left me alone. Theres nothing another person can do to impose their will on me, I will fight it till I die. I usually do the exact opposite of what they want even if I have to sacrifice myself to do so. If you ask me that's fine I will think about it, you demand it....
YOU DONT WANT A KID LIKE THAT!
There are two types of respect. One you earn and one you take with fear, overt actions or retribution. Which one do you want!
What you do next will affect him and her the rest of their lives. It sounds like her parents are total nutjobs. If you FORCE him to he will find a way to be with her if that's what he wants. Let me tell you teenagers as most people love to have sex.... Think about it. If the only place they can meet is school.... If he gets caught at school having sex he gets a rap sheet or worse. If she turns 18 she could be charged with rape. She already is loosing out on being a Cheerleader for her Senior year (right?) and being grounded for who knows how long. (She probably didn't have many privileges to start with. That's pretty harsh IMO.) Also the harder you push to break them up the harder they will in turn fight to be together. Like you said you DON'T want to be a Grandma yet... Right?!?
If you aren't careful you will mess him up in the head. I still have problems from the way I was treated as a teen and child. I am not your normal person to start with but still. Trying to control someone and own them because they are YOUR CHILD and you own them and the house they are in is wrong!
I am not saying he should have no rules. You need to meet him middle of the road. Trust goes both ways. If he trusted you to start with about this situation he would have told you up front. He obviously didn't, think WHY to yourself. Maybe he was protecting her. Maybe he knew how you would react. If he were 18 I bet you would be acting the same, his age isn't the question here. At 15 you make decisions that affect the rest of your life. Your goal at this time is to try to DIRECT him to make the right ones. You can't force him. His sneaking out after you MAKING him promise is proof of that. There is ALWAYS more to a story than you know or thought of.
Treat him with respect regardless of your decision. Do you want them to RUN AWAY together? You aren't leaving them with much choice..... Also are you SURE her home isn't abusive?
Sorry if I came off to strong. I have lived in his shoes, NO I don't have teenagers. Owning teenagers doesn't make you parent of the year people.....!
I hope you can view this post and gain information from it. I just get riled up when I see something so obviously lopsided as most of the posts on here, when the posters haven't been in his shoes. Being a parent doesn't mean your situation is the same as Patchofheavens kids. He doesn't seem to be weak in the mind, I can't say that for most people growing up right now.

Bubba
