I agree with oldchick here, I agree with the SSS as well, and I agree with the scoop him up hold him upside down and take to you neighbor. I have used all 3 but in a different order. SSS was the LAST scenario, and it was NOT with a rooster, it was a dog.
If you do SSS I am pretty sure your neighbor will get another one from the sounds of it and you will be back to square one. I would talk to your neighbor first, tell him what happened, if he has any compassion at all he will feel bad and work to keep him at home. If he doesnt, then go the route of holding him upside down by the legs and delivering him to his owner. The water may help if that doesnt work. If all ELSE fails, Brewster is you baby - do what you need to to protect your flock.
I know how much you care for Brewster and I am SO glad he's ok. I can sympath. on your feelings, we all have been there - done that - and feel SOOOOO bad about it. Give him some extra luvn, treats, and time. He will still luv ya!
ps I have used a shotgun to shoot in the air when i have had a squabble and it instantly stopped the fighting for about 30 seconds. Long enough for you to get ahold of the bad one and take him out of the way to stop the squabble. No one hurt. A can of gravel with a lid shaken has worked for me as well.
My neighbor just kind of "has" a rooster. He doesn't really care about it. The rooster is a gorgeous guy, really, and he's good with the hens, but he hates people and roosters. He put a good size scratch on my thigh, and I just
know that next time it will be a gash.
Brewster is already warming up again, but he is still learry of me. I am still traumatized from this-I thought I had killed him. Yesterday, the rooster came back over and was fighting with Brewster , who was out free ranging.
I am sick and tired of this crap, and I am so tempted to sic the GSDX on that rooster the next time he comes over. I just really don't want to solve this problem by killing the rooster. Ignorant people make me so mad!
As for my rooster, Merlin (We call him The Rebel Rooster), he is, indeed, very, very aggressive. He hassles the girls, chases me, and flogs me every time I turn my back. This, too, is getting old, but, like Comet, I hate to see the problem solved by killing the rooster. I wish there was another way, but is has become apparent that there really is not another way, which means dad has a rooster he needs to dispatch.
I know this is a part of chicken(animal) keeping, and I have accepted that, but I just wish it wasn't so. I am giving the neighbors one last warning, and if they do not take action, I will, and they will not like what I do.