Not vilifying, just a small correction, the post said they were praying, it did not say they were praying to Christ. Normally a prayer before a game is for God's guidance. Since, Jewish people believe in God and pray to him frequently I am betting the Jewish player was fine with it.
On a personal side, if I went into a community that was primarily Hindu, I would never expect them so back off on their chosen display of religious beliefs just because it made me fell like an outsider.
Nope one does not need to be a fervent fundamentalist Christian to have a place here. However, it would be nice for those that are and those that are not, to treat each other with compassion
.