- Sep 1, 2010
- 131
- 15
- 126
I couldn't agree more. A true scientist understands the value of input from others ("peer review") and doesn't storm off in a snit because a few people have issues with what you've put out there. I have no intention of reading through the whole thing to see if he was unjustifiably criticized because it doesn't matter, it's still pathetic to behave this way. But the little I've read it appears to be an overreaction. If someone's criticism is unwarranted, then you can either rebut it or ignore it, but don't delete it because right, wrong, controversial or not, it still moves knowledge and understanding forward. It is sad.This is so sad.
![]()
All these informative posts (by everyone) over the last few days have been revolutionary for my state of knowledge. Each presents information in a different way so it become more comprehensible. Pretty sure there is much no-one actually yet knows but each person adds a different angle/snippet of info to the big picture.
That is how science moves forward, and the whole point of scientific papers.