Anyone going to the show at Lima next week? My granddaughter is taking a pair of young Buckeyes and I am taking a mature pair. I am scared to pieces! What if I find out that my Buckeyes aren't as good as I think they are???!!!!! It is my first show and I understand there are a lot of Bucks entered.......
It's fun. People are nice... especially to kids. If she is confident enough to ask for pointers, it's better if she asks than you. Strike up a conversation with other people with Buckeyes. And listen all you can.
The point of going is largely to find out what you have. Are these birds worth keeping, worth breeding, worth messing with? I am always glad to get an answer to that either way. Over time you'll learn too how far to trust any one evaluation, and always to use your own eyes too. With the first breed that we kept, I decided over time that ours weren't the best... but that we didn't really enjoy what was winning as the "best," so we don't pursue that breed any more. With another, I got a very good critique but I also came to realize that the line had a lot of positives, and that the goal my daughter had (breeding standard quality birds of that particular challenging variety) was quite different from the critiquer's goal, which was to win Best in Show, so they were worth keeping after all. And with Buckeyes, I learned that our original birds were pretty decent but also where they could and should be better. We're very excited about the baby chicks we have this year.
What's important is that you enjoy the birds that you have, and the goals that you have, and not get wrapped up into someone else's goal. If it turns out you need "better" birds... well, the good news is that they are out there to be had. And if you like yours, then no worries.
Wash your birds before the show, make sure they're free of parasites, remember your leg bands, get your kit together, try to arrive early, stay mellow, and ask polite and patient questions whenever you don't know what to do.
Bring a camera or a camera phone so you can take pictures of cage cards and birds that interest you and of your own placings. (That's my fallback for record keeping... the digital photos!)
Have a good time!