Announcement The Coop Page / Article Rating & Review Project!

Pics
Date sort Score sort
granny hatchet said:
what if, and I truly dont understand , this is why I am asking. What if all the plans are there in great detail along with tons of pictures only to see its 2x4 ft coop ? Does it still get 5 stars ? Or what if the coop is so so but they have worked their butts off on the best run you have ever seen ?
Click to expand...
Well, some people are looking to build a 2x4 coop. I would say if it’s got tons of tips, plans, materials list, bunch of photos from building and after finishing, and it’s a solid build that is a good example of what is advertising then I would probably give it 5 stars.

A great run but flawed coop might get 2-4 depending on how it was written with a comment why. The bottom line is so that people can browse these pages and get good advice, tips, and ideas for what they personally want. There’s no point in showing 1-3 amazing pictures of their decked out awesome coop/run that no one could possibly ever recreate. Looks cool but useless for a coop building article.
 
Tesumph said:
Well, some people are looking to build a 2x4 coop. I would say if it’s got tons of tips, plans, materials list, bunch of photos from building and after finishing, and it’s a solid build that is a good example of what is advertising then I would probably give it 5 stars.

A great run but flawed coop might get 2-4 depending on how it was written with a comment why. The bottom line is so that people can browse these pages and get good advice, tips, and ideas for what they personally want. There’s no point in showing 1-3 amazing pictures of their decked out awesome coop/run that no one could possibly ever recreate. Looks cool but useless for a coop building article.
Click to expand...
So if you find one that has none of these things do you give it a star or a review or pass it by ? Im not knowing there is any coops like that , dont get me wrong I just wonder.
 
granny hatchet said:
So if you find one that has none of these things do you give it a star or a review or pass it by ? Im not knowing there is any coops like that , dont get me wrong I just wonder.
Click to expand...

I have given one star ratings and I make polite notes in the comments as to what flaws I see.

Not always easy for someone as blunt and plain spoken as I am. :p
 
granny hatchet said:
So if you find one that has none of these things do you give it a star or a review or pass it by ? Im not knowing there is any coops like that , dont get me wrong I just wonder.
Click to expand...
Personally, I give 1 stars to articles that show 1 or two pictures and a paragraph or less of writing. Those are no help to people even if they’re pretty. Sometimes I make these anonymous if I feel uncomfortable for whatever reason.
 

Similar threads

BYC Project Manager
    • Love
    • Like
Open Contest Official BYC Coop Page Contest #15
Replies
9
Views
8K
Noraaaaa
Noraaaaa
casportpony
    • Love
    • Like
Open Contest Official BYC Article Writing Contest - #23
4 5 6
Replies
58
Views
6K
HomesteaderWife
HomesteaderWife
3KillerBs
Solved Rating/Review Box Vanished
2
Replies
15
Views
2K
3KillerBs
3KillerBs
R
Do all coops struggle with heat in the summer?
2
Replies
10
Views
399
Lrnadoon
L
MableGertyDillys
    • Like
    • Love
Henlay's recycled Gothic plastic coop review !
Replies
3
Views
360
Appalachickens
Appalachickens

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom