Ok so I am rather new but as we have all witnessed there is a ton of confusion on the EE vs Ameracauna. I think the real issue is that non-standard Ameracauna need a new name such as "non-standard Ameracauna). Easter Eggers are technically a cross breed chicken that lays a color egg so Ameracauna x leghorn or Isbar x cochin....just made those up. So what the hatcheries are saying is that if they are breeding Ameracauna chicken to Ameracauna chicken and it is resulting in Ameracauna chicken why should they change the name. Now I know this is not the case with all hatcheries i.e. single combs, no beards, brown eggs (colored leghorns haha). But some hatcheries are actually breeding Ameracauna's together they are just not as selective and are not looking at the APA, they are filling a niche in the market that loves all the "surprise" colors.
It is like anything else that is hatchery it is not up to APA standards. I have seen Brahmas that look like Dalmatians but they are still a Brahma b/c a Brahma was bred to a Brahma but if you mix a dark Brahma & a light Brahma you get a kind of spotty/splashy black & white Brahma still a Brahma. Type is the most important when it comes to breeding. Color can be corrected more easily.
Hopefully I don't get kicked off here haha
It is like anything else that is hatchery it is not up to APA standards. I have seen Brahmas that look like Dalmatians but they are still a Brahma b/c a Brahma was bred to a Brahma but if you mix a dark Brahma & a light Brahma you get a kind of spotty/splashy black & white Brahma still a Brahma. Type is the most important when it comes to breeding. Color can be corrected more easily.
Hopefully I don't get kicked off here haha
