Post some more pictures of Number 3. and take some pictures of them together. My eye is drawn to #3 due to the depth and length of the keel bone, better proportions. #1 and #2 seem to pose with more thigh showing and less depth of keel. The overall #3 color looks more uniform in the picture and maybe wider feather. How do their mothers/hens look? Who is the closest to the line with the "peas in a pod" look? Who feathered out the fastest? Do they all have clean, non striped hackels? Who has the best under-color? Do any of their qualities get you closer to where you want to be when paired to one of your available hens and her comparable qualities?
It would be fun to see the possible match ups that you could make.
It would be fun to see the possible match ups that you could make.