Both parents had single combs and you hatched a chick with a rose comb?I bought three Single Comb White Leghorns from a breeder in January at a show. I put them with my male. One of the females lays a cream colored egg. That should tell me something. I hatch some chicks and some of the chicks have black in their wings and some turned out with Rose Combs. I think there is a mix in there somewhere. The fellow had a Rose Comb that looked in body shape like a White Leghorn. He said kit was a RC RIW. I think he may have had some crosses. I put the male in with my SC White Leghorns and all the chicks came out looking like SC White Leghorns, no odd coloring at all, so I suspect it was the female that lays the cream colored egg.
View attachment 2157181View attachment 2157182
This is their coop so there is no way another male could have gotten in and mated with them. The outer coops are in the background.
View attachment 2157183