@lalaland I agree with you. Here is what I posted in the PM. It's long. Sorry.
Bumblefoot PM
Hello! By looking at your photo and hearing your descriptions I, at this point, would probably not do anything invasive with those feet. If it doesn't look like an active infection I wouldn't intervene.
Now this is just opinion and experience so I want to give you my thoughts and experience below.
I DO have a new item I have purchased and put in my first aid kit that I would use on the feet that I haven't tried before that I can send you a link to. It is non-invasive.
All this being said, if there
IS an active infection and
the surgery is indicated, I would do the "surgery". I'm not convinced my girl that I did it on needed it.
So...here's my experiences. Please read the whole message before going to the link. Sorry it's so long!!!!!
***************************************
I had bumblefoot on one of my girls last winter.
Here is a link that summarizes what I did.
https://www.backyardchickens.com/t/...eeping-thread-ots-welcome/10760#post_10829288
HOWEVER...
I want to say that I have come to a couple of conclusions since I did this so I want to share those
before you look at the link above.
I have several birds last spring that had what looked like the beginning of bumblefoot.
NONE of them were showing any signs of pain or infection. Just the dark circle on the foot. One of the birds that looked like it may have an infection I brought in and soaked one time in epsom salt so that I could get a better look at what was going on. On all the birds on which I saw dark circles, I put some
coconut oil on their feet and leg scales for a couple of days and did nothing else. I didn't bandage at all. I just watched for
signs of obvious infection which is even easy to see from the top of the foot.
None of these have developed into any "active" infection.
I kind-of have a theory/conclusion about bumblefoot in general that I am operating out of at this point which is based on my experience with the girl this winter.
So here it is: I think that people have been so afraid of bumblefoot that we've felt that we need to work on it when it "sometimes" didn't need it.
So I have started to operate this way: If I don't see ACTIVE infection (which will be obvious), I take a watch and see approach. I look for signs of infection locally, and I watch the behavior of the bird. If the bird is bright and acting normal, and there are no visible signs of active infection, I have taken a hands-off approach, even when there is some darkening or scab on the foot.
So far I'm finding that they are all healthy and well, and it seems that their own immune systems are handling whatever may have caused the scab in the first place.
2 winters ago when my original girl (in the link) had bumblefoot,
she began to act like she wasn't feeling well. She would do the classic "hunker down and fluff up" thing. Just prior to that we saw blood drops on the roost bar that is in front of the nest boxes which prompted me to look at each bird individually. I think the blood was actually from a comb, but when I looked at them I saw the scab on one foot and a bruise-like appearance on the other on this girl. I had noticed a day prior that she had started "hunkering down" so I began to work on her feet.
She DID have active infection on that foot, but it was on the side and between one of the toes on top. That is what I originally lanced.
At this point, I'm convinced that I didn't need to do the surgery on the BOTTOM OF HER FEET as, when I got in there, there was nothing that appeared to be infection or a kernel. I DID need to lance the infection on the side and top.
So...just wanted to know what I'm thinking at this point. As I said before, I think that people have been so afraid of bumblefoot that we've felt that we need to work on it when it didn't need it.
That being said...
-I generally reserve antibiotics as a last resort.
-I do like the epsom salt soaks but I would also use those at first to determine what's going on since it cleanse things up so you can see better what the problem is.
-I found that the
icthammel ointment seems to have had the best success with drawing out the infection. (Drawing Salve) You can get this in the regular drug store for people but it is a smaller container that is higher in price.
-
Nustock is very good for many things. I always keep it in my animal first aid kit. It has a strong smell, but it's a GREAT anti-fungal/antibacterial.
-I know folks recommend vetrycin. It is not designed for bumblefoot, but is a nice anti-bacterial. I have some in my first aid kit but have never used it. I would not use it for bumblefoot myself. Even the company that makes it states that they don't see it as a good bumblefoot remedy.
-I would use the biopsy punch for any surgery in which there is infection and in which the kernel doesn't readily come out.
I know a gal that has did the epsom salts soaks last summer for a LONG TIME. She was using the ointments (icthamol and/or Nustock) and wrapping several times a week. The scabs never went away totally, but there was no active infection. Just last week she decided to put
coconut oil on them and wrapping (which another friend of ours had great success with) and it seems that they are looking better than they have all summer.
If that particular bird was mine, I would not have continued with treatment once I determined that that there was no active infection. I would have let the scabs take care of themselves.
NOW SOME QUESTIONS FOR YOU:
-Do you see active infection?
-Is the bird appearing "off" at all from it's normal behavior?
Edited because I left something in from corespondence with someone else formerly that didn't apply.