Leah's mom, thats the trouble with roosters - they just cause chaos.
The broody was joined by her sister, who went broody this morning and climbed in the nest with her. I checked later on and the broody had rolled all of the eggs I gave her out of the nest, and was sitting on two new eggs from her sisters. Can they tell eggs by color? why would she roll out the eggs from the other chickens? will they still hatch if she stays broodY/ I took her sisters eggs away and replaced the original eggs but they were cold. But it is the first day!
Advice?
birds can't count... I would wait until she's been broody a good week, without fail, before giving any eggs... also, I would separate broody hens, for just that reason. I have girls that have brooded on the same nest successfully, but they didn't incubate the eggs, I did. they just shared the chicks once I gave them some.