Leah's Mom, I know this was quite a while ago now that you wrote this, but I'm still working my way through the thread. I feel the same way, and I was wondering if you would care to share your experiences since you posted that? Did it work out the way you had hoped or did you need to make some compromises? (Apologies if you've already written about this and I just haven't read it yet.)
@Amanita
Sorry so long in reply!
I think you're asking if I was ever able to produce my own from my flock. I have not been totally successful with that as of yet. I did have a broody hatch a few of our eggs, but since haven't been successful in finding a great rooster. Currently I'm "roosterless".
I love the SFH since they're all different colors - a "landrace" and very pretty. But I just sent my last sfh to a new home a couple weeks ago. I may have someone hatch some for me in the spring along with a couple other breeds. They are definitely not "dual purpose" though they are marketed that way. If you get them, don't buy from the hatcheries. Not sure what they are but they're not sfh.
I'm going to wait until spring and try these:
I want to try Dominiques as one of my breeds. I've met some and they were a vary enjoyable personality. It seems that they were likely the chickens our great grandparents would have had. They should definitely be dual purpose, but I'm to the point that it would be hard to butcher my layers. I don't mind raising meat birds just for meat, but my flock is small enough the I know each bird. (I still have some 5 yos from my original flock that lay almost every day.)
I have wanted a broody breed. That has made me want to try a couple of Buff Orpingtons. They would also be dual as they are large enough. I mostly want them because of the possible broodiness.
Then I read about bantam Dominiques...and true to the bantam legend, they are supposed to be broodies as well. I may possibly skip the buff O's and just get a few bantam Dominiques but the jury is still out for me on that. I like a varied color flock rather than a bunch of birds that all look alike (Thus, one reason I like the sfh.)
I currently have 2 Buckeye girls that are 1 yo. They are a great personality and also dual purpose breed. I was going to keep one of the cockerels but personality was bad on that boy and I don't put up with that anymore. Nor do I put up with mean hens anymore. I used to try to work with them but decided that there are enough birds with a good personality in the world that chicken soup sounds much better than the whole flock suffering with the meanness of one.
Anyhow...Not sure if I'll ever be at a place where I'll be hatching all my own but it would be wonderful if it could happen!