haven't tried the let it freeze, thaw, freeze thaw method of pumpkin feeding. I don't have anywhere outside to keep such things that wouldn't be first eaten by critters.Okay...do they eat the pumpkin pretty well when you bake it? I have TONS of pumpkins I got for the "kiddos" and they still don't seem particularly excited about them. I really want them to eat it raw after the freezing and thawing like we were told about. Maybe I'll try again!
I always have volunteer "pumpkins" in the field, and I bring them in and keep them for distractions for the chickens. I have found if I rinse off the field dirt, and dunk them into a water with a bit of bleach in it, I can keep them until about Feb without rotting. So I can dole them out for the chickens. In the fall, I don't bother baking them. In the cold winter, when I am baking something else, if I have room in the oven I throw a pumpkin in - whole, just stabbed with an ice pick so it doesn't explode.
Make a treat for the girls, I just cut it in half. Over the course of a few days, they will eat it down to a very thin shell.
I know some people have said their chickens won't eat them, I've never in more than a decade had chickens that wouldn't eat pumpkins, squash, etc.