I have never ever had a broody that I couldn't discourage after a few days . So I've never had a broody sit on a nest. This hen, however, didn't care what I did to discourage her and kept going back to the nest no matter what. She is pretty funny, she got so she would tuck an egg under each wing so when I would lift her off the nest, she would take the eggs with her . Took me a while before I figured that one out!
I gave her blue and brown eggs to hatch, no idea if they are fertile or not. She and her sisters lay cream eggs, so I'll be able to pull any out that get laid daily.
I like those broody boxes I saw in other threads - a long rectangular box made of scrap lumber - just the frame of a rectangle, wrapped in wire, with a cardboard box for the nest at one end. put it in the run, broody and chicks are safe but everyone sees each other. course, the little coop run isn't really big enough or waterproof...
Wow, your broody was very determined! Too funny with the eggs!
I like the idea of a broody box as well. I was trying to get DH to make one and put it on the wall of the coop so it didn't take up floor space, but it wasn't happening anytime soon. I put a cardboard box in the back corner of the dog crate and just put it on the floor of the coop. Ms. Broody-butt is locked in there with food and water and room to stretch a bit, and she is still able to see the flock. The coop is cramped now but the ducks especially don't spend much time in there.
We are on day 3 now and she is a content Broody sitting well. I can't wait to candle the eggs for the first time on day 7 and experience the changes in the eggs!