You need to compare apples to apples. You seem to be compareing Hatchery Stock chicks to Eggs from Show Quality stock, though you can not gauratee that you will get show quality from high priced eggs, but your chances are greatly increased. Go to a show and buy(or I should say try to buy) chicks from a show quality hen, and I bet it will not be $2 a chick like those you may get from a hatchery. Depends what you are looking for, if just wanting to get some chickens to run around your yard and lay eggs, then by all means I would get mine from a hatchery, But if you plan to Breed/Show then its in your best interest to start with the best you can afford. I would NEVER pay $50 or more for a dozen eggs, but there are many on here that if they offered up thier eggs(See Lavender Orphington or Silkie Auctions) for ONLY $50 would have a line at thier door to get those eggs, even knowing that shipped eggs are always a gamble, and that 50% of thier hatch will be Roos.