Please know that I am not criticizing your birds but rather critiquing your birds because you requested such. Both are nice looking birds.
That being said, I would work on getting better leg color, there appears to be an absence of mottling in the chest and there should be some, there is also some fluff visibility at the base of the tail and I would work to eradicate that. Beak color on the second male is better. Eye color appears to be very good. Thus far I like the combs and wattles. Tail carriage appears to be good in both. Overall Type appears to be ok but pictures are hard to judge that by. If I had to pick one for Type over the other, I'd go with the second from the pics.
I prefer the darker coloration in the hackles and saddles but both are within the Standard and probably much more a matter of personal preference - both by you and the particular judge. I would tend to believe the darker hackles on the male will lend itself to darker hackles in the females which is what I'm after.
One thing I will point out is that there may be a hint of white in the sickles of the second male. Keep an eye on that. If any white develops, cull it.
That's all I can see from a quick glance. Having said that, I'd keep them both if you plan on breeding. Getting to where you want them to be is a long road and a methodical process. Lose your only remaining male and it can set you back big time. Besides that, they're both still young and more changes are to come.
God Bless,