These are boys, right?

[PlymouthRockBBredSebright]

this is a rose comb i have had many chicken experts tell me so

 

[MillersFarm]

this is a rose comb i have had many chicken experts tell me so

Sorry are you talking about your bird or the OP's birds? If you're talking about the OP's cockerels than both you and whoever told you that apparently does know the difference between a Pea and a rose comb

 

[wf1992]

View attachment 1323313 see HER comb? its like yours

So pretty!

I'd love for any of mine to be girls, but not holding my breath. And I don't need 4 boys!! I'd just hate to jump the gun and accidentally give away girls...

 

[PlymouthRockBBredSebright]

Sorry are you talking about your bird or the OP's birds? If you're talking about the OP's cockerels than both you and whoever told you that apparently does know the difference between a Pea and a rose comb

talking about MY hen she has rose comb

 

[Redhead Rae]

The bottom two, look like girls to me and the top two look like boys.

 

[MillersFarm]

So pretty!

I'd love for any of mine to be girls, but not holding my breath. And I don't need 4 boys!! I'd just hate to jump the gun and accidentally give away girls...

I think it's safe to say you have boys, Pretty ones at that. If you lived near me i'd take the first one in a heart beat

 

[Mylied]

It's not the type of comb, it's the amount of color on it at 2 months old that's the problem. Can you do a full body side shot so we can see if they have any tell tale male feathers? Most likely, those are cockerels. But I did have some wyanodotte pullets pink up early. Top left is definitely male because of his coloring.

 

[MillersFarm]

talking about MY hen she has rose comb

Thank you for clearing that up with me.

 

[TheKindaFarmGal]

They are cockerels, and have pea combs. The male feathering - the long and stringy hackle, saddle and sickle feathers - start coming in when they are 10-12 weeks old and might not be obvious for a while after that, so you can only go off comb size and color right now.

 

[wf1992]

In fairness, I haven't posted pics of the 2 who appear to actually be girls - their combs are much smaller and not at all red.

I guess I'm wondering if there's any chance of them developing at such different rates that they'd fool me into thinking they were boys. Only 2 exhibit the classic boy - chest bumping, neck feather flaring - behaviour.