While I would certainly use plenty of caution with craigslist, I don't think it's that odd that someone might be willing to drive that far for a cat.
This. He's already neutered. Their gas money for that is a lot less than the fee to spay/neuter a cat would be. When we adopted our last cat, we did some driving - about 30 miles. The owners getting her to us? Drove 80. Craigslist is littered with cats and kittens who are moderately, or not at all, taken care of - much less vetted. An adult, already altered, cat who has some sense? MUCH harder to come across (and admittedly harder to place).
This. He's already neutered. Their gas money for that is a lot less than the fee to spay/neuter a cat would be. When we adopted our last cat, we did some driving - about 30 miles. The owners getting her to us? Drove 80. Craigslist is littered with cats and kittens who are moderately, or not at all, taken care of - much less vetted. An adult, already altered, cat who has some sense? MUCH harder to come across (and admittedly harder to place).