I have found that Nordstrom sizes work for me and they have narrow, regular and wide. Most importantly, they have leather. But, I don't skimp on shoes. My balance is not so great these days, so I am very particular.
Mom said she had to buy Clarks for me as a little kid as they were the only ones that didn't fall off. They aren't a cheap shoe, but Amazon has sales and I'm really good at checking. They make a nice loafer style.
I cannot have any pressure on the tops of my feet anymore. Wearing Birkenstocks for 30+ years caused me some issues with bone spurs on top that became bone plates that the nerve runs over. Laced shoes cripple me in a few weeks of wearing.