Unfortunately sports seem to revolve around winning, and not about allowing everyone to belong.
The sense of belonging is critical to success. There was a mention on the news yesterday about popularity in high-school, and adult earnings. It comes as no surprise to me, because of course those who can charm, play well with others, and belong are going to win more. Those with a sense of "belonging" will always have an easier adulthood.
If sports can teach this then great, otherwise I was able to give my children this skill through other means.
I agree. Between my 3 kids ages 10 and under, I have sat through and watched 22 different seasons of sports. My daughter excels. My boys have been put down and made fun of, ironically, by the adults, not the kids. At a young age, kids are accepting of each other. ALL of the boys on every single team my boys have played on have been accepting of them.
As a sports parent, I have been able to "fit in" with other parents when my daughter is playing. Parents want us around, and she gets put in. She has never been benched.
When my boys have played, we've gotten glares from parents. At end of season, coaches have gushed over the athletic ability of other boys, only to say things regarding my boys like "I'm not even sure what to say about this boy". Thanks for saying that in front of 30-some adults and a team of kids. Not.
Until our kids started playing Upward, I walked away from every single end of season party that my boys attended, gotten in the vehicle and burst into tears. Upward changed things for us. Upward is an educational league, not a competitive league. They test the kids prior to the season and design teams that will be competitive so no team will win or lose more than the others. Games are scored, but the score is tossed as soon as the game is over. No one is supposed to track the wins/losses of the season. This is how a game goes where our kids play... at the beginning of each game, kids are called out one by one with motivational music playing in the background. The crowd cheers - for every kid. Every kid plays 1/2 of every single game. No one is benched. At the end of each game, every kid is awarded a star and the coach is required to say something nice about the child and explain what he/she did in the game to earn that star - this makes the coaches have to find and focus on the positives of each child. At the end of the season, a booklet is put together with every child's name in it and what team they were on. Every child gets called up, by name, on stage and given a gift. It's amazing to watch somewhere close to 600 to 800 people packed into a room and cheering each kid on. There are no winners. There are no losers. Everyone gets a chance to learn how to play a sport and be part of a team. It is church-based, but I would guess about half the kids who play in Upward don't go to church at all.
Upward was designed because of what you described - the need for every child to feel like they belong. I wish Upward had been around when we were growing up.