You want a splash rooster that's solid in colour. I'd probably go with a Splash Orpington.
Diploid organisms
Except in the case of sexlinked genes, every chicken possesses two copies of every gene. One copy of the gene was inherited from the mother; the other copy was inherited from the father. The chicken will pass one of these two genes onto his or her offspring.
Alleles:
Some genes have more than one allele, or type. The gene mutated so that it looks different. Such is the case with black and splash. Black (bl) is the original, wildtype gene. Almost every chicken carries two copies of black (bl/bl). In a chicken long ago, black (bl) mutated into splash (Bl). The splash gene dilutes black into blue (Bl/bl).
If you have hens that are black (bl/bl) then to get blue, you need the chicks to inherit splash (Bl) from their father. If the father is splash (Bl/Bl), they'll all inherit one bl from the mother, and one Bl from the father (Bl/bl) = blue. If the father is blue (Bl/bl), then half of his chicks will inherit Bl, and the other half will inherit bl. Half will be (Bl/bl); half will be (bl/bl)
The upshoot: In order to get 100% blue chicks, you need a splash father.
The e-locus:
The e-locus genes determine the pattern of black and gold on the chicken (every chicken colour that exists is some variation of black or of gold). Extended black (E) is the gene that makes a chicken solid black (or some mutation of black, such as lavender, splash, white, or blue). It is dominant to almost all other e-locus genes.
Your hens, for instance, have one copy of extended black, and one copy of wheaten (most likely). Because of this copy of wheaten, they might show some gold leakage around neck and chest, but they're mostly black.
To get solid blue chickens, you want to use a rooster with extended black.