I live next to state land reserved for hunting, deer and turkey. THat means I have coyote cruising thu ( a new face stopped yesterday) and crows and hawks. I also have 2 young children (7&9) And I have plenty of land, some pasture, mostly wooded. I wanted egg layers primarilty, friendly because of my kids, tough enough to cope with hawks and coyote, the right colors to be missed by the hawks.
production reds__tough ( peck when in nest box), dk color to blend in in the shade, mod-gd forager
silver specked hamburg-- a tough rooster who took over the top position, never attacked me or my kids, quick spry, black and white so easy to spot but very alert.
specled sussex--my kids love 2 of mine, very good foragers, great camouflage color
buff orpingtons-- docile, not the best camo color, noted for being the first to be picked off bc of docileness, down the drive foraging further than others
blk sexlinks--they don't visit, kids don't gravitate to them they don't forage; one rooster is aggressive to my kids, the other is a sweetie pie they tote around.
austrolorp--ditto
EE--run to forage first thing in the morning, good camo, easy going, not friendly but manageable
marans--run off to forage with the EE and BO
My favorite overall is the speckled sussex. But they all work together--one sounds the warning and everyone reacts! Even the BBW turkeys ran for cover. Coyote in the yard yesterday, a deer today.
I'll be adding buckeyes.