We had 19 chicks hatch the first week of July and knew we couldn't keep them all - we waited until we knew the roos from the hens and just chose from there. Two went to new homes a couple days ago- they were good strong roos but did not stick out as overly friendly or overly crabby. I brought three to a butcher the other day - we didn't have the heart to do it ourselves with this round because one was our favorite. We chose the three because 1)the first had a very bad cross beak and only one eye - he was such a sweetheart and I still feel awful, but for breeding and guarding purposes he wasn't ideal. 2) the second had very wobbly legs and couldn't roost - he slept by himself in a corner every night 3) the third was already quite feisty. The two we kept were pretty friendly to us so far and good to the ladies. That was our selection process. I just picked them up from the butcher today and at about 18.5-19 weeks old, the three dressed out at 3.5-4.25 pounds. One was a buff cochin/EE cross and the other two were black orpington/? crosses.