I've had excellent experiences with both My Pet Chicken and Ideal. My birds from MPC are beautiful - not typical "hatchery" chicks, in my opinion. The RIR cockeral from Ideal is hatchery typical, but he has an amazingly great temperment, and is very healthy - as were all the chicks from Ideal. I was worried that Ideal would send me lots of cockerals as "warmers" because I ordered only about 10 my last round, but when I contacted them and explained that wouldn't be OK, they were great about not sending them. I'm ordering from them again this year, and am thrilled that they have self-blue or lavender silkies. I know the silkies won't be show quality, or even breeder quality, but it's nearly impossible to get a good quality lavender, since most of the lavender breeders haven't wanted to let them go. As a result, this lets others start breeding lavenders, with the understanding that it will be several years of breeding before anything decent is hatched...
Laura