which silkie cockerel would you keep/is better?

[Amme015]

There both not perfect, but which one would be a better option to keep?
cockerel 1 has horns and his back toes are slightly connected and red-ish waddles
cockerel 2 has this weird red color on his face and red-ish waddles
both don’t have very tight wings
BOTH 18 WEEKS

cockerel 1:

cockerel 2:

 

[MamaPoult]

Hmm I guess #2? Are you keeping them to breed? I try to not keep any genetically "Weird" for lack of better words birds if I am breeding them.

 

[Amme015]

Hmm I guess #2? Are you keeping them to breed? I try to not keep any genetically "Weird" for lack of better words birds if I am breeding them.

im keeping them to show, Thank you for your answer tho! ill keep it in consideration because i am having trouble choosing which i should separate or let go

 

[MamaPoult]

im keeping them to show, Thank you for your answer tho! ill keep in in consideration because i am having trouble choosing which i should separate or let go

Ahh I see! I am not really knowed up on showing birds but I would guess the judges would be less likely to notice #2's discoloration than #1's issues

 

[Amme015]

Ahh I see! I am not really knowed up on showing birds but I would guess the judges would be less likely to notice #2's discoloration than #1's issues

Yeah your right, i agree with that.Thank you so much for the help!

 

[MamaPoult]

Yeah your right, i agree with that.Thank you so much for the help!

Yay! Glad I could be of assistance!

 

[my spoiled chickens]

@Debbie292d