I bred FBCM for a little while.. I had ONE chick pop up with NO feathers on the legs despite selecting HARD in my breeding stock.
The other stuff I see there.. the lack of the copper in one lady, the leakage in the wrong place, and so on.. I will admit that FBCM were a bit challenging.. and I hatched a LOT of chicks keeping VERY few.. in my experience only 1% of chicks hatched will grow into true breeding/show quality.. Most back yarders cannot hatch that much to improve their stock significantly.. Unfortunately I end up keeping probably more like 10% of what hatches each year.. the rest are eaten or sold as layers to non breeding flocks. What I'm saying ultimately.. is despite not liking everything I'm seeing there.. I FULLY recognize that challenges that arise, and those aren't the worst I've seen! Honestly, people mistake black sex links for Marans way too often when they are a dark bird with that rusty neck.. even then to the untrained eye.. I get it!
KC gave good info.. I had forgotten about sports, it's been a while since I worked with them. But I agree they don't appear to be splash either.. I SWEAR genetics might be what keeps chickens interesting! I have had escapes and accidental mating take place in my breeding flocks.. usually always discovered and dealt with.. but mentioning because things happen to best of us despite our best effort at times.
American Poultry Association can certify that 98% of breeding stock meet the standard of perfection, is what I think I saw previously Greenfire Farms claimed to have one of only few certified flocks, looks like it's changed a but since then.. but for reference to what they say NOW..
https://greenfirefarms.com/marans.html
Thanks for sharing a good mystery and happy chicken adventures!