Who’s white egg is it? Who’s brown egg is it?!

[ChocolateMouse]

It's the eatser egger. Because you don't own an ameraucana. The rest are brown layers.

Edit; I now see you also have a white ear lobed hen unlisted in the opening post. It's from her.
They're not genetically linked but most white egg laying breed standards also call for white earlobes.

It's still an EE tho, not an ameraucana

 

[DiYMama540]

I want to be raising chickens in Hawaii!!!
So jealous!

 

[Lawrence Lovestock]

So here is an update as of today:
Brown egg from our Cuckoo Maran
White egg from our off the street do t know what she is AND ...
today, her first egg... I got a pink egg from our EE! So that’s 3 eggs today!
just waiting on our Brahma now, and not too long after- our RI Reds!

 

[Lawrence Lovestock]

View attachment 1953352 View attachment 1953353
So guess what Gray Farms?!?!!! You were right! The little gal is laying the white eggs! We call her Renegade and she is usually with the turkeys overlooking the flock. We found her on the streets when the Turks were babies to help teach them to eat n drink. So technically she’s been around since the very beginning and must be 6-7 months old, about a year older then the other 3 hens! She’s like 3x smaller than the other hens, what do you think her breed is? By the way ... Thanks for the observation!!

Not a year older, I meant a month older...