Has a lot to do with location. We decided to get rid of all our chickens. We had a good mix and they haven't laid since October. We don't use very many eggs anymore so they were very cost ineffective. We put them in for 5.00 each or 50.00 for all. We had 13. Twelve people replied. We went in order of response. The 1st five all made plans to meet us and didn't show. Some even e-mailed or called with excuses and can you hold them. After 7 days the 6th guy who only lived around 3 miles away showed up. He had lost his whole flock to a fox and was going to start with chicks in March. He was very happy to get a nice flock from us. They all looked very nice. The rooster was a beautiful EE.
Craigs List is full of wacky inconsiderate people. There are good ones mixed in. How much are you charging? You might be high for your area or you may need to come down some to get people to go the extra mile. Our flock had a mix of 1,2,3 year olds. Some people just don't place the value on chickens that other people do.