All I'm saying is don't tell people what to do with their dogs because you believe its right. The OP said she would keep some of the puppies. Some people treat their dogs like their children ( I'm not one of those people, although I do respect their views) if op daughter got pregnant and didn't know how or when, would you tell her to abort the baby, because their are too many babys at orphanages? Or because the babys dad is not the same race? What they do with their dog is their business. Killing dogs at a shelter is not somthing to brag about. Most shelters do more harm than good. They think they are god, deciding which dog lives and which one is adopted out. Dogs that get hit by cars are dogs that play in the street, not dogs that are not fixed.
I'm not going to respond to the majority of this because it's completely unfounded speculation.
There are many many many no kill shelters popping up all over the US. I work for a no kill rescue group and the city closest to me has been 100% no kill since 2010.
As I said before- dogs and humans are not the same and treating them as such in the ways you have stated would be very silly.